🥇 The Best Games of 2021, Ranked by Rating
Published · updated · list data as of
The year of co-op surprises and racing perfection: these are 2021's highest-rated games, ranked by combined critic and player scores.
This list is ranked by combined critic and player scores. Who actually collected the most Game of the Year awards in 2021 is a different question — Meta Awards, our sister project, counted them across thousands of outlets, and It Takes Two and Forza Horizon 5 came out on top.
How selective is this list?
12 of 70 games meet the criteria
- Release span
- 2021–2021
- Median year
- 2021
- from 2015 or later
- 100%
- Median rating
- 78/100
- with couch co-op
- 9%
- most common platform
- PC (91%)
- typical playtime (top 50)
- ~13 hours
Counted live in the IGDB games database on this page’s last build.
How we picked
- Source: the IGDB games database, data as of 6 November 2026.
- Adult titles are excluded.
- At least 50 combined critic and player ratings, so the score means something.
- Ranked by the IGDB total rating.
- 70 games meet the criteria; this list shows the top 12.
- 1

Toem2021
90 / 100PuzzleAdventureIndie - 2

It Takes Two2021
89 / 100PlatformPuzzleAdventure🛋️ Split-screen up to 2 - 3

Forza Horizon 52021
89 / 100Racing - 4

Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart2021
88 / 100ShooterPlatformAdventure - 5

Psychonauts 22021
87 / 100PlatformAdventure - 6

Pathfinder: Wrath of the Righteous2021
87 / 100Role-playing (RPG)StrategyTactical - 7

Returnal2021
86 / 100Shooter - 8

Resident Evil Village2021
85 / 100ShooterAdventure - 9

The Forgotten City2021
85 / 100Role-playing (RPG)AdventureIndie - 10

Deathloop2021
85 / 100ShooterAdventure - 11

Hitman 32021
85 / 100ShooterTacticalAdventure - 12

Tales of Arise2021
85 / 100Role-playing (RPG)Adventure
Read next
🏆The Best Games of 2022, Ranked by RatingElden Ring's year — and nine more reasons 2022 was special.🏅The Best Games of 2023, Ranked by RatingBaldur's Gate 3, Zelda, Spider-Man — a year that refused to slow down.🏆The Best Games of 2024, Ranked by RatingThe year's finest, ranked by critics and players.
Find your perfect game in 8 questions →